Stories

Opportunity, Experience and the Workplace

Matthew Lau
April 7, 2015
Andrew Scheer is pitching a revision to the existing Canada Emergency Response Benefit to incentivize Canadians to return to work. For Matthew Lau, what unskilled workers of any age most want is opportunity. They are willing to trade low wages for experience and, by extension, higher wages in future.
Stories

Opportunity, Experience and the Workplace

Matthew Lau
April 7, 2015
Andrew Scheer is pitching a revision to the existing Canada Emergency Response Benefit to incentivize Canadians to return to work. For Matthew Lau, what unskilled workers of any age most want is opportunity. They are willing to trade low wages for experience and, by extension, higher wages in future.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

austerity

Once again this spring, thousands of Quebec post-secondary students have gone on strike. They are not protesting against tuition fees, which are the lowest in Canada, as they did in massive numbers in 2012, but against the provincial government’s alleged “austerity agenda.” As cheerfully reported by Fightback, “the Marxist Voice of Labour and Youth”, more than 5,000 students and youth recently took to the streets in Montreal, “chanting anti-austerity, anti-government, and anti-capitalist slogans.” The march was organized by the local chapter of the Canada-wide (and unabashedly Communist) Revolutionary Student Movement.

Although such actions may be dismissed as youthful left-wing idealism, the fact is that ideas pushed by radical students on university campuses often have an adverse impact on all students. In particular, students’ unions often spend large amounts of time and money – expropriated from the student body via mandatory student union fees – on lobbying for economic policies that will harm students. A good example is their ongoing campaign for higher minimum wages.

Leading the charge is the student union-funded Canadian Federation of Students, the largest student organization in Canada. In 2013, the CFS lobbied for a $14 minimum wage in Ontario, which would have been a 37 percent increase at the time. Currently, the CFS is fighting for a $15 minimum wage in British Columbia and in Nova Scotia, which represents a 46 percent increase in BC and a 44 percent increase in Nova Scotia.

Students’ unions and activists often say higher minimum wages are needed to reduce poverty. However, there is wide agreement among economists that the relationship between changes in the minimum wage and changes in the poverty rate either does not exist or is very weak. In Canada, only 1 in 8 minimum wage earners live in poor households. For governments concerned about poverty reduction, there are surely more effective policy options than a minimum wage.

While minimum wages are ineffective in reducing poverty, they do play a significant role in reducing employment. Jobs are lost when government sets a minimum wage that exceeds a worker’s capacity to add value to a company. Young workers, who tend to be unskilled and inexperienced, and who constitute the majority of minimum wage earners, suffer the heaviest job losses. The economic evidence indicates that increasing the minimum wage by 10 percent in each Canadian province would result in a 3-6 percent reduction in the employment rate for young workers. Increasing it by upwards of 40 percent, as recommended by the CFS, would have an exponentially greater negative impact on youth employment.

It logically follows that one way to effectively reduce the high levels of youth unemployment in Canada would be to lower the minimum wage. What young people starting out in the working world need – even more than money – is opportunity and experience. A low minimum wage would create more of both. The same argument applies to any unskilled worker – not just youth – whose primary concern is getting a foot in the door, and then working his or her way up.

Evidence that young Canadians are willing to trade low wages for experience (and by extension, higher wages in the future) can be seen in the growing popularity of low-paid and unpaid internships. Current estimates suggest there are as many as 300,000 Canadians working in unpaid internships. Assuming the vast majority are students, that’s about 15 percent of the two million people enrolled in post-secondary institutions in Canada today. Volunteering is what students do – contrary to what some of their elders might think. More than half of Canadians aged 15-24 participate in volunteer activities each year, the highest rate of any age group.

It must also be pointed out that working for low wages (or no wages) is not a permanent situation – those who improve their skills and work hard are eventually given the opportunity to move up the income ladder. According to a recent Fraser Institute study, 87 percent of Canadians in the lowest income quintile in 1990 had moved out of the lowest quintile by 2009. Data from other sources confirms that intergenerational economic mobility is higher in Canada than in either the United States or the United Kingdom.

Besides increased employment prospects, lower minimum wages deliver another important benefit to students: lower consumer prices. A review of nearly 30 American studies cited in a 2011 report by the Canadian Federation of Independent Business found that a 10 percent increase in the minimum wage results in up to a 4 percent increase in prices. The corollary is that a decrease in the minimum wage would result in a decrease in prices – and benefit students who are always looking for ways to economize.

Since higher minimum wages increase unemployment and consumer prices without reducing poverty, and given the fact that so many students are already working for free, a case can be made for lowering, or even abolishing, minimum wages.

Of course, there would be other impacts. Lowering or scrapping the minimum wage could put downward pressure on wages, thereby swelling the ranks of the so-called “working poor.” But theoretically, at least, this cohort would also benefit from increased employment opportunities. And the Canadian economy, including its hard-pressed manufacturing export sector, would benefit from more competitive labour costs. Even taxpayers would win, since many minimum wage positions, particularly for students, are either government jobs or taxpayer-funded via government summer job grants.

Therefore, while a high minimum wage may benefit some workers, the economic inefficiencies and unemployment associated with it are too high a price to pay. Far from lobbying for increases in the minimum wage, students and other Canadians should actually be campaigning to abolish it.

~

Matthew Lau is a finance and economics student at the University of Toronto.

Love C2C Journal? Here's how you can help us grow.

More for you

The Housing Market Isn’t Racist. Blame Your Parents Instead

Diversity may be our strength. But it is now alarmingly commonplace in Canada to blame any perceived diversity in outcomes between racial groups on vaguely-defined “systemic racism” or “white supremacy”. Case in point: the Federal Housing Advocate’s allegations of rampant racism in Canada’s housing market, and the need to address it with outlandishly disruptive policies. Delving deep into Statistics Canada’s ample supply of race-based data, Peter Shawn Taylor considers the evidence for racism in Canadian housing, education, income and poverty statistics, and finds a more convincing explanation much closer to home.

Young Offenders: Meet the Angry Socialists Poisoning Our Politics

Social media is widely blamed for poisoning the public conversation on a range of topics – especially politics and contentious social questions. But there’s a possibly even more dangerous force growing on the internet: an online community of YouTubers and livestreamers spouting far-left dogma, praising political violence and denigrating their opponents as evil, far-right fascists. Using fallacious arguments, psychological manipulation and overheated rhetoric, they seek to radicalize young people and convert them to their cause. Millions are tuning in, and mainstream “progressive” politicians are jumping on their bandwagons. Noah Jarvis profiles three of these socialist crusaders and explains why they are such a threat.

The Worrisome Wave of Politicized Prosecutions

Shaping criminal charges, bail decisions or prison sentences around an accused person’s political or religious beliefs is utterly odious – a hallmark of tinpot tyrannies and totalitarian hellholes. Such practices have no place in any constitutional nation, let alone a mature democracy that presents itself as a model to the world. But that is increasingly the situation in Canada, writes Gwyn Morgan. Comparing the treatment of protesters accused of minor infractions to those of incorrigible criminals who maim and kill, Morgan finds a yawning mismatch that suggests political motivations are increasingly a factor in today’s criminal justice system.

More from this author

Trudeau’s Economic Incompetence in Seven Charts

A picture may be worth a thousand words, but a good chart can explain billions. With just a few simple lines, a chart can bring complicated economic facts into sharp focus – revealing, for example, the growing gap in living standards between Canada and the U.S. since 2015. Or the $127 billion in excess spending by the federal Liberals even before the pandemic hit. Or the impact of the recent spike in inflation. Using seven custom-created charts, Matthew Lau illustrates and explains the financial devastation wrought by the Trudeau government’s fiscal policies throughout the Canadian economy. Troublingly, Lau’s final three charts suggest the worst is yet to come.

Erin O'Toole won the leadership of the Conservative Party of Canada by promoting a "big tent", but what does that coalition mean?

An Unwise Union: How Workers Will Suffer From Erin O’Toole’s Embrace of Big Labour

Erin O’Toole became leader of the Conservative Party of Canada on the strength of his Big Tent vision for the party. But how big should that tent be? Recently O’Toole surprised commentators by extolling the benefits of the union movement and repeating many of its claims as Conservative policy. Matthew Lau charts the origin of this unorthodox political strategy, and its worrisome economic implications. If the Conservatives want to attract workers’ votes, he argues, they should start by recognizing the damage done by unions to growth and job creation.

The Right To Be Fat: Pushing Back Against Government Overreach

Would beloved comic actor John Candy have lived longer if government forced him to eat less? What about Orson Welles? Or Luciano Pavarotti? Perhaps. Would they have been happier or more successful? We’ll never know the answer to the first, and as to the second, almost certainly not. Candy built his career around a lovable portliness, Welles often played menacing fat men and Pavarotti’s girth helped him belt out arias. A few extra pounds, in other words, offers both advantages and disadvantages − and it should be up to the individual to decide how to balance the scales. As governments ramp up policies designed to put their citizenry on a diet, Matthew Lau sallies forth in defence of eating what you want, and exercising only when you feel the need.

Share This Story

Donate

Subscribe to the C2C Weekly
It's Free!

* indicates required
Interests
By providing your email you consent to receive news and updates from C2C Journal. You may unsubscribe at any time.